body

bone

At a glance

עצםetzem
bone, itself
hard, durable, closed-up (Rav Hirsch); the general term for any bone (Wertheimer); the outer surface (Vilna Gaon)
גרםgerem
bone, itself
one member of a larger system (Rav Hirsch); the big load-bearing bones (Wertheimer); the inner cavity with its marrow (Vilna Gaon)

In short

Both mean bone, and both also mean the thing itself. Rav Hirsch explains that etzem is the bone as something hard, strong and self-contained, and gerem the bone as one part within a frame, which is why the same root gives a single step of a staircase and, in rabbinic Hebrew, grama, indirect causation. For Rabbi Shlomo Aharon Wertheimer, etzem is the general word for any bone, and gerem specifically the larger bones that carry a heavy load. The Vilna Gaon puts the line differently: etzem is the bone's hard outside, gerem the hollow inside where the marrow is.

Distinctions

Etzem (עצם)

Yosef charged his brothers to carry his atzamos out of Mitzrayim (Bereishis 50:25), and Moshe took them (Shemos 13:19). The same root gives the reflexive pronouns atzmi, atzmo, atzmecha, literally "my bones," for "myself." Hebrew has several such words for the self, each naming a different part: nafshi from the soul, gufi from the body, galmi from one's matter, atzmi from the bones. Menachem Ibn Saruk lists five senses of ע-צ-ם: bone; a visible hue (Shemos 24:10; Eichah 4:7; Tehillim 139:15); strength (Bereishis 26:16; Shemos 1:7, 1:9; Yeshayahu 40:29, 41:21; Tehillim 38:20); shutting the eye (Yeshayahu 29:10, 33:15); and the thing itself (Bereishis 7:13; Shemos 12:41). Rabbi Shlomo Pappenheim joins etzem to atzum, strong, and to eitz, a tree, since the bone is the hard part of the body as the trunk is of the tree, against the flimsier growths; Ramban (to Vayikra 23:28) had already said that a thing's etzem is its strongest point.

Gerem (גרם)

The Targumim typically render etzem with garmei, in the sense of bone and in the sense of self alike; the Aramaic appears in Daniel 6:25. In Hebrew the noun is written gerem but usually pronounced garem under the influence of the cantillation and vocalization (Mishlei 17:22, 25:15). "A soft tongue breaks a bone (gerem)" (Mishlei 25:15), said of the power of prayer to overturn harsh decrees from Above, is plainly the body part. The self-sense may already be seen in gerem hamaalos, the step itself (Melachim II 9:13); it would seem, Rabbi Klein writes, that gerem as bone gives gerem as self the same way etzem does, a man's self being sometimes characterized by the hardest parts of his body. Rabbi Eliyahu HaBachur notes the rabbinic extension to causation, gorem, grama, garmi, seen already where Targum renders sabosi, I brought about, as garamti (Shmuel I 22:22), and running through the Gemara and the poskim. Rabbi Shlomo Pappenheim derives gerem from the two-letter ג-ר, temporary lodging, the bone being where the marrow and the body's moisture are housed, alongside ger (a sojourner), goren (the grain's temporary home), nigar (gathered water), and garger (a grape holding its juice); Rabbi David Chaim Chelouche argues the same from the marrow.

Two further terms belong here. Garmei shamayim, the celestial bodies, in Rambam's Moreh Nevuchim and other works rendered from Judeo-Arabic, are independent "selves" in the heavens. And hagramah (Chullin 9a), cutting at the wrong point of the animal's throat so that the shechitah is invalid, may belong to gerem as well (see Rashi to Melachim II 9:13 and Maggid Mishnah, Hilchos Shechitah 3:12).

Where the authorities disagree

How etzem and gerem differ. Three accounts:

  1. Whole against part. Rav Hirsch (to Bereishis 49:14, Shemos 1:7, Bamidbar 24:8, Devarim 25:4, Tehillim 139:15): the two words can name the same body part, but etzem attends to its strength and durability, which he groups with osem (storing up), chosem (blocked), and otzem (shutting the eyes), since something strong is closed and self-contained; gerem attends to the bone as one piece of a bigger structure. Gerem hamaalos, a single step of a staircase (Melachim II 9:13, and see Metzudas Tzion there), illustrates the point; hence, for Rav Hirsch, grama for causation as one link in a causal chain, and hence the verb of ג-ר-ם for breaking, that is, pulling the parts of a system apart.
  2. General against large. Rabbi Shlomo Aharon Wertheimer: etzem is the general word for bone of every kind. A fetus is at first fleshy tissue, and as it develops parts of that tissue close up and harden into bone (Iyov 10:11; Chullin 89b). Gerem names specifically the larger bones, the ones that carry a heavy load, which is what Yaakov invoked for Yissachar.
  3. Outside against inside. The Vilna Gaon, commenting on "a broken spirit dries the gerem" (Mishlei 17:22): etzem is the hard outer surface of the bone, gerem the cavity within, where the marrow lies. Rabbi Klein adds that the tie of gerem to the liquid marrow may find precedent in Tanach if one juxtaposes that pasuk with "a good report fattens the etzem" (Mishlei 15:30); the juxtaposition is his, the distinction the Gaon's.

Rav Hirsch's reading explains the rabbinic grama, and the Vilna Gaon's bears on his ruling on germani below.

Chamor garem (Bereishis 49:14). Yaakov's berachos compare several sons to animals, Yehudah to a lion cub (49:9), Dan to a snake (49:17), Naftali to a gazelle (49:21), Binyamin to a wolf (49:27). What, then, did he call Yissachar?

  1. A strong-boned donkey. Rashi: garem is etzem, so the blessing is a strong donkey able to bear heavy burdens, fitting a tribe of talmidei chachamim who take on the yoke of Torah (see also Rabbeinu Bachya there). Rabbi Yaakov Emden reaches the same result from causation: the bones are the frame on which the body stands, so they cause the animal's stoutness.
  2. A bony donkey. Ralbag, exactly the reverse: a donkey so poorly fed that its bones show, and therefore too weak to go out, like the scholars of Yissachar who stay in their place, against Zevulun's merchants who cross the sea.
  3. A donkey caused it. The Gemara (Niddah 31a) reads garem as "caused": Yissachar was born because Yaakov's donkey brayed as he came in from the field and Leah went out to meet him (Bereishis 30:14-18; see Sefer HeAruch s.v. chamra). The Tosafists offer another route to the same reading: mandrakes were said, by a long-standing legend, to shriek lethally when uprooted, so they were commonly harvested by starving an old donkey and clearing the area of people, leaving the animal to pull them up and die of the shriek; apparently the dudaim in the trade between Rachel and Leah were got that way, so a donkey "caused" Yissachar to be born.

Yigarem (Bamidbar 24:8). Bilam's blessing that Israel will consume their enemies "and their bones yigarem."

  • Menachem Ibn Saruk (Machberes Menachem): ג-ר-ם has two senses, bone and breaking, and here it means they will break them; Rashi cites him.
  • Rashi himself prefers gnawing: scraping (gorer) the meat off the bone with the teeth and sucking out the marrow, leaving the bone bare (see also Rashi to Yechezkel 23:34).

Germani (Negaim 2:1). The Mishnah says the whitest shade of tzaraas looks dim on the skin of a germani.

  • Rambam (commentary to the Mishnah) and Rabbi Tanchum HaYerushalmi (HaMadrich HaMaspik) derive the word from gerem, since bones are white, so a germani is a man of especially white skin.
  • The Vilna Gaon (Shenos Eliyahu there) does not accept this and takes germani as a member of the European tribes of the lands the Romans called Germanica.

Rabbi Klein suggests it is likely the Gaon's own distinction that drove him: if gerem is the bone's interior, tying germani to it becomes problematic, since that is not the part whose whiteness one sees.

Also discussed in

Radak on these roots

Sefer HaShorashim

ג-ר-ם

A bone, as the Targum renders עֶצֶם, bone, גַּרְמָא; the verb, to break the bones; and גֶּרֶם הַֽמַּֽעֲלוֹת, the steps themselves or a step.

Strong of bone

יִשָּׂשׂכָר חֲמֹר גָּרֶם (Bereishis 49:14), Yissachar is a donkey of bone, he takes as strong and big of bone, bearing a great load, and this is what the pasuk says, וַיֵּט שִׁכְמוֹ לִסְבֹּל, he bent his shoulder to bear. Rabbi Yonah takes it as broken and unable to stir from his place, from וְעַצְמֹֽתֵיהֶם יְגָרֵם (Bamidbar 24:8), he will break their bones.

Breaking the bones

וְעַצְמֹֽתֵיהֶם יְגָרֵם is he will break the bones, and in the same way יְשֹׁרָֽשׁוּ (Iyov 31:8) is he will take away the roots. In the light form, לֹא גָֽרְמוּ לַבֹּֽקֶר (Tzefaniah 3:3) is either that they did not tear prey, since a lion or a wolf in tearing breaks the bones by morning, or that they left not even the bones for morning; and by way of borrowing, וְאֶת־חֲרָשֶׂיהָ תְּגָרֵמִי (Yechezkel 23:34), you will break its shards.

The steps

אֶל־ גֶּרֶם הַֽמַּֽעֲלוֹת (Melachim II 9:13), onto the very bone of the steps, that is, onto the steps themselves; or else it is in the sense of a step. Yonasan renders it שַׁעֲיָא, which Radak explains as the step that carried a mark for the hours of the day; and so Yonasan renders צֵל הַֽמַּֽעֲלוֹת (Yeshayahu 38:8), the shadow of the steps, טוּל אֶבֶן שְׁעַיָא, the shadow of the stone of the hours.

גְּרָמָיו כִּמְטִיל בַּרְזֶֽל (איוב מ, יח), עצמיו ודומה לתרגום עֶצֶם (בראשית ב, כג) גַּרְמָא. וכן וְרוּחַ נְכֵאָה תְּיַבֶּשׁ־גָּֽרֶם (משלי יז, כב), וְלָשׁוֹן רַכָּה תִּשְׁבָּר־גָּֽרֶם (משלי כה, טו), יִשָּׂשׂכָר חֲמֹר גָּרֶם (בראשית מט, יד), רצה לומר חזק ובעל גרמים וסובל משא גדול וזה הוא שאמר וַיֵּט שִׁכְמוֹ לִסְבֹּל (שם). ורבי יונה פירשו שבור שאינו יכול לזוז ממקומו מן וְעַצְמֹֽתֵיהֶם יְגָרֵם (במדבר כד, ח). אֶל־גֶּרֶם הַֽמַּֽעֲלוֹת (מלכים ב' ט, יג), בשש נקדות על עצם המעלות כלומר אל המעלות עצמן, או הוא כענין מדרגה. ויונתן תרגם שַׁעֲיָא, רוצה לומר המדרגה שהיה בה סימן לשעות היום. וכן תרגם צֵל הַֽמַּֽעֲלוֹת (ישעיה לח, ח), טוּל אֶבֶן שְׁעַיָא. וְעַצְמֹֽתֵיהֶם יְגָרֵם ישבר הגרמים. ועל הדרך הזה יְשֹׁרָֽשׁוּ (איוב לא, ח) יסיר השרשים. ומבנין הקל לֹא גָֽרְמוּ לַבֹּֽקֶר (צפניה ג, ג), כלומר לא טרפו כי האריה או הזאב בטרפם ישברו הגרמים לבקר. או פירוש לא השאירו אפילו הגרמים לבקר. ובדרך ההשאלה וְאֶת־חֲרָשֶׂיהָ תְּגָרֵמִי (יחזקאל כג, לד).

ע-צ-ם

Strength, force and greatness; עֶצֶם, a bone, so called as stronger than flesh; from it the body, and likewise the body of any thing. Another sense: to close the eyes.

Strength

כִּי עָצַמְתָּ מִמֶּנּוּ (Bereishis 26:16), for you have grown mightier than we, and רַב וְעָצוּם (Shemos 1:9), many and mighty. The nouns are עֹצֶם, as כֹּחִי וְעֹצֶם יָדִי (Devarim 8:18 in his edition), my strength and the might of my hand, and לֹא־נִכְחַד עָצְמִי מִמֶּךָּ (Tehillim 139:15), my strength was not hidden from You; in another pattern עֶצֶם, as זֶה יָמוּת בְּעֶצֶם תֻּמּוֹ (Iyov 21:23), this one dies in the strength of his wholeness; and עָצְמָה, strength. The sense of them all, he says, is strength, force and greatness.

The force of an argument

It is said of the strength of a quarrel as well: וּבֵין עֲצוּמִים יַפְרִיד (Mishlei 18:18), it parts the strong, that is, those who stand strong in a quarrel, and הַגִּישׁוּ עֲצֻמוֹתֵיכֶם (Yeshayahu 41:21), bring forward your strong points, the force of your suit and your proofs. So in וְנָפַל בַּֽעֲצוּמָיו (Tehillim 10:10), and falls by his mighty ones, the sense is by the force of his quarrels and his wars, עֲצוּמָיו being an adjective for quarrels that are strong and wars that are mighty. Chazal use it so (Sanhedrin 31b): שנים שנתעצמו בדין, two who pressed one another at law.

The bone

עֶצֶם מֵעֲצָמַי (Bereishis 2:23), bone of my bones, with a masculine plural, עֲצָמִים, and a feminine one, עַצְמוֹת. In כַּֽעֲצָמִים בְּבֶטֶן הַמְּלֵאָה (Koheles 11:5), like the bones in the full womb, the bones are the unborn child in the womb of the woman with child. The bone is called so, he says, because it is stronger and firmer than the flesh. The doubled verb is וְזֶה הָֽאַֽחֲרוֹן עִצְּמֹו (Yirmiyahu 50:17), and this last one has broken his bones.

The body, and the body of any thing

Since the bone is the strength of the body and holds it up, the body itself is called עֶצֶם: אַךְ עַצְמִי וּבְשָׂרִי אָתָּה (Bereishis 29:14), surely you are my bone and my flesh. Where flesh is named beside it, he says, the bone does not mean bone alone but the body, and the flesh after it says the same thing twice; Chazal use עצם for the body often (Shabbos 31a): הלך הוא בעצמו, he went in his own person. Radak allows that עָצְמִי in לֹא־נִכְחַד עָצְמִי מִמֶּךָּ (Tehillim 139:15) may be like these too, though it is of another pattern, meaning my body: my body was not hidden from You. Likewise any thing is called עֶצֶם: בְּעֶצֶם הַיּוֹם הַזֶּה (Bereishis 7:13), which he glosses בגופו של יום, in the body of this day, and וּכְעֶצֶם הַשָּׁמַיִם לָטֹהַר (Shemos 24:10), כגוף השמים, like the body of the heavens for purity.

Shutting the eyes

וְעֹצֵם עֵינָיו מֵרְאוֹת בְּרָע (Yeshayahu 33:15), and shuts his eyes from looking on evil, and וַיְעַצֵּם אֶת עֵינֵיכֶם (Yeshayahu 29:10), and He has shut your eyes. Their sense, he says, is closing.

וְעָצַם כֹּחוֹ וְלֹא בְכֹחוֹ (דניאל ח, כד), כִּֽי־עָצַמְתָּ מִמֶּנּוּ (בראשית כו, טז), וְֽאֹיְבַי חַיִּים עָצֵמוּ (תהלים לח, כ) עָֽצְמוּ־לִי אַלְמְנוֹתָו [אַלְמְנוֹתָיו] מֵחוֹל יַמִּים (ירמיה טו, ח), רַב וְעָצוּם (שמות א, ט), וַֽעֲצֻמִים חַטֹּֽאתֵיכֶם (עמוס ה, יב). והשם כֹּחִי וְעֹצֶם יָדִי (דברים ח, יח), לֹא־נִכְחַד עָצְמִי מִמֶּךָּ (תהלים קלט, טו). ומשקל אחר זֶה יָמוּת בְּעֶצֶם תֻּמּוֹ (איוב כא, כג), בשש נקודות, רצונו לומר בתוקף שלמותו. ומשקל אחר וּלְאֵין אוֹנִים עָצְמָה יַרְבֶּֽה (ישעיה מ, כט), וכן כּוּשׁ עָצְמָה (נחום ג, ט), חטף והמסורת עליו ב' ירבה ודין. ופירושו כוש היה לך לעצמה כמו שאמר (שם) פּוּט וְלוּבִים הָיוּ בְּעֶזְרָתֵֽךְ. ובסמוך בְּעָצְמַת חֲבָרַיִךְ (ישעיה מז, ט). ומשקל אחר וְתַֽעֲצֻמוֹת לָעָם (תהלים סח, לו). והפעל הכבד [הִפְעִיל] וַיַּֽעֲצִמֵהוּ מִצָּרָֽיו (תהלים קה, כד), ענין הכל החוזק והתוקף והגדולה בענין האיכות והבטוח. וכן נאמר לענין חוזק הריב וּבֵין עֲצוּמִים יַפְרִֽיד (משלי יח, יח), כלומר בין המתחזקים במריבה. הַגִּישׁוּ עֲצֻמוֹתֵיכֶם (ישעיה מא, כא), תוקף ריבכם וראיותכם. וכן בדברי רבותינו ז"ל בזה הלשון (סנהדרין לא, ע"ב) שנים שנתעצמו בדין. וְנָפַל בַּֽעֲצוּמָיו חֵלכָּאִֽים (תהלים י, י), בתוקף ריביו ומלחמותיו. ועצומיו תאר לריבים התקיפים ולמלחמות החזקות. עֶצֶם מֵֽעֲצָמַי (בראשית ב, כג), בשש נקודות. דָּבְקָה עַצְמִי לִבְשָׂרִֽי (תהלים קב, ו), פירשנוהו בשרש בָּשַֹר. עֶצֶם אֶל־עַצְמֽוֹ (יחזקאל לז, ז). והקבוץ בלשון זכרים כַּֽעֲצָמִים בְּבֶטֶן הַמְּלֵאָה (קהלת יא, ה), רוצה לומר העובר אשר בבטן ההרה. והקבוץ בלשון נקבות אֲסַפֵּר כָּל־עַצְמוֹתָי (תהלים כב, יח), הָֽעֲצָמוֹת הַיְבֵשׁוֹת (יחזקאל לז, ד), וְעַצְמֽוֹתֵיכֶם כַּדֶּשֶׁא תִפְרַחְנָה (ישעיה סו, יד), וְעַצְמֹֽתֵיהֶם יְגָרֵם (במדבר כד, ח), ידוע. ונקרא כן לפי שהעצם חזק ותקיף מהבשר. ולפי שהעצם חוזק הגוף ומעמידו נקרא הגוף עצם, אָדְמוּ עֶצֶם מִפְּנִינִים (איכה ד, ז), בשש נקודות. אַךְ עַצְמִי וּבְשָׂרִי אָתָּה (בראשית כט, יד), עַצְמְךָ וּבְשָֽׂרְךָ אֲנָֽחְנוּ (דברי הימים א' יא, א). ואף על פי שזכר בשר עם העצם, העצם שזכר אינו מיוחד על העצם לבד כי אם על הגוף, ובשר שזכר אחריו הוא כפל דבר כי גם בשר לבדו יאמר על הגוף כמו שנאמר וּמִבְּשָׂרְךָ לֹא תִתְעַלָּֽם (ישעיה מח, ז) שהוא הקרוב שהוא כגופו של אדם. ובדברי רבותינו ז"ל הרבה נזכר העצם במקום הגוף באמרם (שבת לא, ע"א). הלך הוא בעצמו. ויתכן להיות כמו אלו אף על פי שהוא משקל אחר לֹא־נִכְחַד עָצְמִי מִמֶּךָּ (תהלים קלט, טו), כלומר גופי. וכן כל דבר יקרא עצם בְּעֶצֶם הַיּוֹם הַזֶּה (בראשית ז, יג), בשש נקודות בגופו של יום. וּכְעֶצֶם הַשָּׁמַיִם לָטֹֽהַר (שמות כד, י), כגוף השמים. והפעל הדגוש [פִּעֵל] ממנו וְזֶה הָֽאַֽחֲרוֹן עִצְּמֹו (ירמיה נ, יז), פירוש שבר עצמותיו. וענין אחר וְעֹצֵם עֵינָיו מֵֽרְאוֹת בְּרָֽע (ישעיה לג, טו). והכבד [פִּעֵל] וַיְעַצֵּם אֶת־עֵֽינֵיכֶם (ישעיה כט, י), ענינם הסתימה. וכן בדברי רבותינו ז"ל (שבת פרק שלשה ועשרים משנה ה. דף קנא, ע"ב) המעצם עיניו של מת קודם יציאת הנשמה הרי זה שופך דמים.

Radak, Sefer HaShorashim, Berlin 1847. Public domain, digitised by Sefaria from the National Library of Israel.

Rav Pappenheim on this root

Cheshek Shlomo

ג-ר

In English, our account of his entry

Dragging (גרירה): a thing drawn along from place to place, not rolled; of the living, one with no fixed home who moves from place to place, a גר, sojourner.

Flowing slowly

Of things without life, dragging is slow flowing: וכמים הנגרים (Shmuel II 14:14), "like water that runs off"; ויגר מזה (Tehillim 75:9), "and He poured out of this"; עיני נגרה (Eichah 3:49), "my eye runs". What moves slowly is נוזל, flowing; what comes down drop by drop is נוטף, dripping; and what comes down slowly, neither fast nor drop by drop, is said to יגר, run down. So פרץ נחל מעם גר (Iyov 28:4), "a torrent broke out from where it trickled": from a place where the water only ran gently, a rushing stream burst out.

גרם, the bone with marrow

With a mem added, a bone that holds marrow is גרם, named for the marrow and the fatty juice that runs into it; a bone with no marrow is עץ, wood, since it has dried out like wood, as he explains at the root עץ. יששכר חמר גרם (Bereishis 49:14), "Yissachar is a donkey of bone", is a donkey whose bones have marrow in them. The verb, ועצמתיהם יגרם (Bamidbar 24:8), "and their bones he will drain", is doing something to their bones so as to suck out the marrow in them; and ואת חרשיה תגרמי (Yechezkel 23:34), "and you will suck its shards dry", is sucking out the juice that has run into them. אל גרם המעלות (Melachim II 9:13), "onto the gerem of the steps": the gerem is, as it seems, a kind of gutter into which the water off the roof runs.

גרגר, a berry

So too the berry: שלשה גרגרים בראש אמיר (Yeshayahu 17:6), "three berries at the top of the bough". Each single berry of a fruit, into which the juice runs, is a גרגר.

Stones dragged about

כאבני גר מנפצות (Yeshayahu 27:9), "like stones of gir, smashed", are stones dragged about over the face of the field with no one to gather them. The verb is והגרתי לגי אבניה (Michah 1:6), "and I will drag her stones down into the valley"; and from the same sense, והגרם על ידי חרב (Yirmiyahu 18:21), "and drag them off by the power of the sword", and וכסאו לארץ מגרתה (Tehillim 89:45), "and his throne You dragged down to the ground", where מגרתה is like הגרת, You dragged, the mem standing in place of a heh.

גרון and גרגרת, the throat

גרון, the throat, is from dragging: קרא בגרון (Yeshayahu 58:1), "call out with the throat", so named because food and drink are dragged down from there into the belly. The windpipe, called גרגרת, bears the name too, because it is joined to the גרון: וענקים לגרגרתך (Mishlei 1:9), "and necklaces for your neck", since the גרגרת shows more on the outside than the גרון, which is the gullet.

גרה, the cud

The food dragged to the throat is גרה, the cud: מעלה גרה (Vayikra 11:4), "brings up the cud".

Small coins, גרה and אגורת

A small coin is also גרה: עשרים גרה השקל (Shemos 30:13), "the shekel is twenty gerah". It is named for dragging, because it is dragged constantly from hand to hand and never stays fixed in its place, unlike the heavy coins that are stored away in a treasury. The same is לאגורת כסף (Shmuel I 2:36), "for a piece of silver", a small coin of whatever kind.

אגרת, a letter

אגרת, as את אגרת הפורים (Esther 9:29), "this letter of Purim", is a writing passed through the whole country from man to man to make its matter known in public. In parentheses he adds צירקולער, a circular.

The saw and the carpenter

The saw is מגרה, as מגררות במגרה (Melachim I 7:9), "sawn with a saw", named for the way it is used: not lifted like other tools but dragged over the wood, which splits apart. After this tool the language of the Talmud calls the חרש, the craftsman, נגר: נגר ולא בר נגר (Avodah Zarah 50b), "a carpenter and not a carpenter's son", the craftsman who works with the saw. A craftsman is always called after the tool he does most of his work with: the tailor is חייט after the חוט, the thread he sews with, and the shoemaker רצען after the מרצע, the awl; so the חרש is נגר because most of his work is with the saw.

אגר, gathering

Also from גרר is the verb אגר, gathering: a gathering that comes by dragging, collecting different things from different places, a little at a time. אגרה בקציר מאכלה (Mishlei 6:8), "she gathers her food in the harvest"; אגר בקיץ (Mishlei 10:5), "he gathers in summer"; ויין לא תשתה ולא תאגר (Devarim 28:39), "and wine you shall neither drink nor gather". The noun is מגרה: נהרסו ממגרות (Yoel 1:17), "the granaries are torn down", and העוד הזרע במגורה (Chaggai 2:19), "is the seed still in the granary?", a store gathered by dragging. Sometimes the alef drops: יגרהו בחרמו (Chavakuk 1:15), "he gathers him in his net", that is, יאגרהו ויאספנו, he gathers and collects him; יגורו עלי עזים (Tehillim 59:4), "the mighty gather against me", gathered against me from every side; and על דגן ותירוש יתגוררו (Hoshea 7:14), "over grain and wine they gather". The noun from it is מגור, as מגור מסביב (Tehillim 31:14), "dread on every side", formed like מקום, place, and מרום, height.

גרן against מגורה

With a nun added, גרן, the threshing floor: גרן ויקב (Hoshea 9:2), "threshing floor and winepress"; כתבואת גרן (Bamidbar 18:30), "as the produce of the threshing floor". It is the place where grain not yet threshed is gathered. That is how it differs from the מגורה: the מגורה is the store of threshed grain, the גרן the store of unthreshed grain and of the sheaves.

גור, to fear

From גר in its sense of gathering, the verb גור was borrowed for fear and dread: ויגר מואב (Bamidbar 22:3), "and Moav was in dread"; לא תגורו מפני איש (Devarim 1:17), "do not fear any man". Either it is gathering in to oneself, for fear of being exposed and spreading outward; or it is the gathering and collecting of all one's thoughts so as not to come to harm, as with יראה and מורא, fear, which, as he will explain in their place, come from seeing and watching.

מורא against מגור

מורא applies when the one afraid knows the one way he could be harmed and need only watch that way alone. מגור applies when the ways of harm are many, and he must gather all his thoughts and consider every way harm could possibly reach him. How the words of fear, מורא, מגור, חיל, אימתה ופחד (fear, dread, trembling, terror and fright), differ from each other is left to their own places.

גרה, provoking; and חרחור

Also from dragging is the verb גרה, provoking and quarrel: אל תתגרו בם (Devarim 2:5), "do not provoke them"; ואל תתגר בם מלחמה (Devarim 2:9), "and do not provoke them to war"; מתגרת ידך (Tehillim 39:11), "by the strife of Your hand"; איש חמה יגרה מדון (Mishlei 15:18), "a hot-tempered man stirs up strife", an act that drags quarrel and strife after it. It is close to חרחור, as אל תתחר במרעים (Tehillim 37:1), "do not grow heated over evildoers". But חרחור is from חרון, burning anger: the intent to do something that brings on burning wrath. גירוי, provoking, is the intent to do things that will draw one's fellow into dispute, and so it is a cause that drags the quarrel after it as its result. In the language of the Talmud a cause is גורם: זה וזה גורם (Pesachim 26b), "this and that both cause it"; דבר הגורם לממון (Pesachim 5b), "a thing that brings about money".

גר against תושב and אזרח

Of the living, dragging gives the noun גר: כי גר יהיה זרעך (Bereishis 15:13), "your seed will be strangers"; גר ותושב (Bereishis 23:4), "a stranger and a settler"; האזרח והגר (Vayikra 16:29), "the native and the stranger". גר describes one who sojourns in a land not his own, the opposite of the אזרח, who was born in the land where he is. A תושב is one not born here who has taken up his dwelling like one of the land's native-born; a גר is one not born here who also has no fixed home to settle in for all the days of his life.

אזרח, from rising

אזרח is from זריחה, rising. The verb זרח marks the first appearing of anything, as והצרעת זרחה במצחו (Divrei HaYamim II 26:19), "and the tzaraas broke out on his forehead"; so the sun's first appearing on the horizon is called מזרח, as מזרח השמש (Yehoshua 1:15), "the rising of the sun". זריחה is not said once the sun already shines on the land, only of its first coming out and appearing on the horizon. So one who lives in the land of his birth is called אזרח, one found in the place where he rose and first appeared in the world. ומתערה כאזרח רענן (Tehillim 37:35), "spreading out like a fresh native", means like the rising, the first appearing, of a fresh tree, which right from the start of its growth is thick and stout and full of branches; there אזרח is a word that describes, not a noun.

גור, to sojourn and to dwell

The verb from גר: ויגר אברהם (Bereishis 21:34), "and Avraham sojourned"; האחד בא לגור (Bereishis 19:9), "this one came to sojourn"; לגור בארץ באנו (Bereishis 47:4), "we have come to sojourn in the land"; ארץ מגריהם (Shemos 6:4), "the land of their sojournings". It means dwelling that is not fixed. Sometimes it is said of fixed dwelling as well: אגורה באהלך עולמים (Tehillim 61:5), "I will dwell in Your tent forever"; לא יוסיפו לגור (Eichah 4:15), "they will dwell there no more".

גור, a cub

From dwelling, the young of wild beasts is גור: גור אריה יהודה (Bereishis 49:9), "Yehudah is a lion's cub"; רבתה גוריה (Yechezkel 19:2), "she reared her cubs"; היניקו גוריהן (Eichah 4:3), "they suckled their young". It is called גור because it dwells in its den and its hole and does not yet go out to roam the land for prey, the grown beasts bringing it food. So ותעל אחד מגריה כפיר היה וילמד לטרף טרף (Yechezkel 19:3), "she brought up one of her cubs, he became a young lion and learned to tear prey": she brought one of her cubs up out of the hole, and it grew and became a כפיר, the lion that roams the villages, the כפרים, for food, and only afterwards learned to prey. Since the young lion preys more fiercely than the old, the tribes are likened, where preying is meant, to a lion's cub, a young lion, even though as long as it is a cub it does not prey.

Rav Shlomo Pappenheim, Cheshek Shlomo (Shorashim), first printed from his manuscript by Moshe Tzuriel, Bnei Brak 5777. The English is our account of his entry.

Sources

Rabbi Reuven Chaim Klein, "Them Bones and Themselves," What's in a Word?, Ohr Somayach, 7 January 2023.

Cited in the essay: Bereishis 7:13, 26:16, 30:14-18, 49:9, 49:14, 49:17, 49:21, 49:27, 50:25; Shemos 1:7, 1:9, 12:41, 13:19, 24:10; Vayikra 23:28 with Ramban; Bamidbar 24:8; Devarim 25:4; Shmuel I 22:22; Melachim II 9:13; Yeshayahu 29:10, 33:15, 40:29, 41:21; Yechezkel 23:34; Mishlei 15:30, 17:22, 25:15; Tehillim 38:20, 139:15; Iyov 10:11; Eichah 4:7; Daniel 6:25; Niddah 31a; Chullin 9a, 89b; Mishnah Negaim 2:1; Sefer HeAruch s.v. chamra; Machberes Menachem; Shenos Eliyahu to Negaim 2:1; Maggid Mishnah, Hilchos Shechitah 3:12.